11 Comments
User's avatar
Benjamin, J's avatar

The question isn't whether Platner is a Nazi. If you think he's a Nazi: you're being obtuse.

The question is whether Platner has the judgment to be a senator, and how does this story fit into that? To be fair: I can forgive someone for being a stupid, young marine making stupid, young marine decisions. I can even, maybe, forgive him for LYING about how stupid he was when he was young. But the lies are piling up. His story is bogus, and he has other...issues that I simply believe show that his current character is not good enough to belong in the Senate.

There are a few million Mainers: why do we need to settle for this buffoon? I'd rather have Susan Collins.

DMS's avatar

If he had any brains, he would show the original tattoo, before he created his “cover-up”.

Justin On Summer Break!'s avatar

I think it's fine to draw an analogy between Platner and someone dropping the heinous word that no melanin deficient person can say. And to be fair, most people are not Nazis, especially most of the people who are called Nazis on social media. At best, it is very bad optics, he should have gotten in front of it when the issue was raised. He didn't, and this has gotten worse over time. Of course people are going to dig up other things about him, it's politics. And it could end whatever career he was considering having in government, which would be his own fault.

Seth Finkelstein's avatar

Random observation. The toy of the "Skull Ship" of the Superman villain Brainiac, looks a lot like that German Panzer Totenkopf. I wonder if it's coincidence, or if the designer was deliberately using that as inspiration for a supervillain's vehicle. Hopefully this doesn't make anyone who has that toy even as a adult, a secret Nazi.

https://www.actionfigure411.com/dc/mcfarlane-super-powers/vehicles-and-playsets/skull-ship-brainiacs-hi-tech-space-craft-7966.php

Seth Finkelstein's avatar

Regarding: "Didn't we decide that was a bad thing when it was happening to people we liked? Why is it ok now?"

Because the Mass Mind is currently deciding, in its somewhat but not entirely inscrutable fashion, if he's liked enough so that condemning him for this is a bad thing. There is no question that he has Violated A Taboo. The issue now, which doesn't have an obvious answer at the moment, is if there is more benefit to be had to "influencers" by condemning him in the standard process as Taboo-Violator, or if he's going to be powerful enough that it's expedient to engage in the rare Forgiveness (and We Will Not Speak Of This Again).

It's the same as how so many Christian Fundamentalists support Trump, even though he's virtually a one-person package of all the Seven Deadly Sins.

Keese's avatar

I don't think he's an actual Nazi, but the people who are supporting him have been very profligate with that accusation over the last decade or so, and they deserve to squirm.

FuriousGreg's avatar

‘I sometimes play chess and play the black pieces so I’m just as much a Black Panther as that black guy with the Black Power tattoo…’

No, the guy may not be a literal Nazi but you’ve got to believe in it enough to knowingly get the most repugnant of their symbols tattooed on your chest.

Knight Erred's avatar

…. Do any of the excuses for his nazi tattoo sound like someone who should be a senator anyways?

“He’s just too retarded and alcoholic to *not* have a nazi tattoo bro. Thats why he *has* to be the deciding vote on the omnibus”

Not so young anymore.'s avatar

He had an SS tattoo and he knew about it. He’s a shitty man. If he was a republican who knows what the Democrats would say?

Steven Fried's avatar

Bullshit. If it was a Confederate Flag tattoo, he’d have been canceled in 20 seconds. But combine a Nazi tattoo with anti-Israel pronouncements and you rush in to defend him because you don’t know what’s in his heart? Please. Just own it. We hold Jews to a different standard. Full stop. It’s already obvious.

Nick's avatar

Your comparison of Nazi tattoos to playing board games is absurd.